Lone survivor lies

Reply to Topic. First of all let me say that I like Lone Survivor as a movie, it is one of the better war movies of the War on Terror era, lone survivor lies, I have watched it several times BUT I have come to believe that particularly the beginning of the operation is a pack of lies, basically gag gifts amazon piece lone survivor lies propaganda designed to cover up a botched operation and protect the reputation or mystique of US special forces, lone survivor lies. What I think did not happen -Being discovered by a Shepard by him standing on their foot, just the odds of them even being discovered in a supposedly concealed position are remote but having one actually stand on his foot is borderline ridiculous. Now whether this comes from Luttrell account or if the standing on foot was added for the movie is hard to find out.

Posted on May 15, SFC Join to see. Anyone that was part of the recovery Responses: 4. Sort By Newest Oldest Votes. COL Join to see. Posted 8 y ago.

Lone survivor lies

This first appeared in The Havok Journal on March 23, Lone Survivor was eventually made into a major motion picture, but that, too, generated significant controversy. I sat with my father in late December watching the UFC fights. This was not the first interview that I had watched where both Marcus and the director touted the extreme attention to detail and accuracy that they sought when making the film. Far too often Hollywood has a tendency to sensationalize stories in an effort to sell more tickets so I was anxiously awaiting a highly accurate portrayal of the entire mission and those involved. To my dismay, that is not what I got. Before I go any further I feel that it is necessary to say that I was a part of the search and rescue operation to pull those men out. My platoon aided in the recovery of Matt Axelson several days after the firefight had concluded. I was awarded a joint service commendation medal for actions during this operation. I have had the distinct honor and privilege of speaking with several other service members from other elements since my book was published. In addition to conversing with several other members of Special Operations that were involved, as well as my own personal accounts, I have to be honest and say that Lone Survivor did little to preserve the historical accuracy of one of the most significant missions in the Global War On Terror. I understand fully that making these comments in a public forum will result in a potential onslaught of negative feedback.

An exceptional leader, or a serendipitous combination of above-average troops, can severely alter the ability of a SEAL team to operate -- and doubly so if they lone survivor lies the least bit over-confident. By manipulating the content young men are convinced that becoming a suicide bomber is the morally correct course of action.

Remember Me? What's New? Last Jump to page: Results 1 to 10 of Thread Tools Show Printable Version. No love to Newsweek, but this is just another confirmation of reports and books that point to Marcus, The Navy, The Book and the Movie being dishonorable liars and tall tales.

Their mission was labeled Operation Red Wing. There was only one problem: After repeated attempts they could not establish clear radio communication with home base. Again, as per protocol. Team Spartan was accidentally discovered by three local goatherds who all but stumbled over them in the mountain undergrowth. After determining that the men were civilians—not combatants—the SEALs faced a quandary. Murphy orders the men released, according to the rules of civilian engagement. It also gives us a glimpse into the reasons these men form a lasting bond of brotherhood and interdependence. Both of those elements come fully into play later as the four members of Team Spartan fight through gunshot wounds and broken bones to protect one another, dragging the injured to safety and going far beyond what most would consider even above-normal levels of physical endurance. In a heroic last-ditch effort to call for help for his comrads, one SEAL climbs a rock outcropping to where his SAT phone might make a connection. In doing so, of course, he knowingly exposes himself to deadly fire from nearby Taliban shooters.

Lone survivor lies

Marcus Luttrell and his team set out on a mission to capture or kill notorious Taliban leader Ahmad Shah, in late June Marcus and his team are left to fight for their lives in one of t Read all Marcus Luttrell and his team set out on a mission to capture or kill notorious Taliban leader Ahmad Shah, in late June Marcus and his team are left to fight for their lives in one of the most valiant efforts of modern warfare. Shane Patton : Been around the world twice. Talked to everyone once. Seen two whales fuck, been to three world faires.

Maternity dress modest

Lone Survivor was eventually made into a major motion picture, but that, too, generated significant controversy. Was it always this way, just without the Internet as venue for people who were there to call bullshit? Nice flick imo but yeah some of the things that happen in the movie are probably not true. Luttrell's lies span both his military service and personal life. Sign Up With Email I have an account. Read This Next. The military intelligence estimate cited by Darack is based on research sourced from intelligence reports, including aerial and eye-witness studies of the battlefield after the fact, including the men sent in to rescue Luttrell, as well as reports from Afghan intelligence. Amid the heroic acts in Lone Survivor 's somewhat sensationalized narrative is a true story that is based on a nonfiction book. As such, Gulab took Luttrell back to his village and insisted the other villagers protect Luttrell until he could be safely rescued by U. The attack began after the team was encountered by civilian goat herders. If even a quarter of that is true, it changes a lot of opinions I have about people.

Laden with weapons and gear, Petty Officer Marcus Luttrell grasped the rope dangling from the rear of the Chinook transport helicopter and descended into the moonless night.

In an effort to increase the necessary Hollywood kill count, the backstory of each of the men was completely lacking. X Favorite Movies. A competitive exerciser and free will admirer. Image resizer by SevenSkins. Instead of being held accountable for their actions and using as a lesson learned going forward, The story was spun, lies were told and awards were given to all parties. View All Lists. I understand fully that making these comments in a public forum will result in a potential onslaught of negative feedback. If you , me or anyone else made up a lie, and profited off it, It would be a crime fraud. Both men appear to have lied repeatedly in their books, in the news, and at public appearances to promote themselves and each other's books. Chuck, we miss ya man. Ever notice how the Navy has never really said to much about the situation other than small PR pieces and hasn't commented on the validity of the story. Movies like Lone Survivor do well to quench our thirst for drama but do little to represent factual events. I am stating my tactical opinion.